Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Spectators, Voyeurs and Cowards


No attempts at literary cuteness today:

The actions, or rather inactions of the spectators, voyeurs and cowards who watched a young woman raped in Richmond, California have left me sick to my stomach.

Have we raised a generation of spectators? Over 20 kids watched one of their own brutally assaulted for more than two hours. Only one young woman had even the decency to call the police?

The kid who dropped the dime is being made out a hero. I'll give you this; she did the right thing. I'm not diminishing the quality of her action; I'm sure she had to consider retribution from her peers. Still it's sad that we consider the most obvious and fundament action we'd expect in this situation an act of heroism.

As a professional in the self-defense industry I'd be the first to give a pass to anyone who might fear getting physically involved in stopping an attack like this. The least you can and should do is call for help. Had any of these kids jumped in and pulled the rapists from their victims I'd certainly acknowledge their courage and heroism.

Those who watched, and photographed, and texted their friends while the rape was still going on are cowards. These kids are a waste of food. My first impulse is to sentence all of them to a televised re-run of the incident with each of them in the featured role.

I had to do some work and some soul-searching to find compassion for the kids who stood by and watched. The fact is that by our legal standards, they had no obligation to help. We've enabled a generation of spectators. We've taught young people to stay out of it, mind their own business, and not get involved. We've told them that someone else's problem is, well, someone else's problem. We've enabled kids to blame others for their behaviors and blame others for their crimes. We've crippled them with entitlements and excused their lack of personal responsibility.

Then I remembered the kids I work with every day. Kids who come to martial arts classes day after day; work hard and focus on improving themselves; kids who understand that respect means taking care of one another and that it's their responsibility to do so. These kids know that the absence of fear is stupidity and that courage is acting in the face of it.

I like to think that most kids would have tried to stop this rape. Most kids would have called the cops.
What's the difference? Why would some kids, and adults for that matter, put themselves in harm's way to protect someone else while others are content, even entertained to stand by and watch?

We've got to stop blaming media, schools and government for these problems. It's time to hold ourselves accountable as parents, teachers and neighbors. It's time to provide the best possible examples we can and insist on discipline, focus, respect and courage from ourselves.

We've got to teach these values early and often. We've got to indoctrinate young people with positive values and role models in order to inoculate them from the insanity we've tolerated for way too long. We're not going to win this war through appeasement, we've got to stay in the fight and make sure our young people are strong enough to face the battle; this war never ends.

We've got to return to the fundamental teaching that sometimes you've got do what might be painful, difficult or dangerous for no other reason than it's the right thing to do.

It's not for me to forgive the young men and women who treated an actual rape like a reality TV show. I hope that for her own health and sanity the victim can find forgiveness for them. I want to stay good and pissed off. I'm hoping this energy will help me stay focused on the important job of training young men and women, and adult men and women, to live a life of discipline, personal responsibility and courage.
These days that's not always an easy job. It is the right thing to do.

Article on reaction to Richmond High rape from Contra Costa Times...

Video on classmates and the young woman who called police from FOX News...

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Jim:
Your contributions on this issue are sadly, spot-on. Thanks for saying what needed to be said.

Anonymous said...

Well said, Jim! I believe that the postmodern ideas being taught that there is no single truth, no real right or wrong coupled with the desesitzation of basic conscience lead to this type of horrifying behavior. Thank you for continuing to focus on the positive development of people, young and old.

Marie Tucker said...

Jim, I share your disgust not only with the rapists but of the others who stood there and watched.

Our teachers and doctors and other adults in an authoritative position are required to report abuse of any kind done to a minor. Why do we not hold other minors accountable as well? But then the question becomes at what age do we hold minors responsible for reporting an abuse. Its a fuzzy line, but that same fuzzy line is what has kept child abuse, and incest swept under the carpet for so long and continues despite the efforts of our brave victims who speak out and fight back.

There is no easy answer but the right answer for me is to teach my children the value of human life and wellbeing and encourage others to do so as well.

My prayers are for the victim who endured this heinous act and now will have to live with the ramifications of not only what physically happened to her but what mentally happened to her by her rapists and the spectators.

Anonymous said...

Well said, Marie...

Linda Snyder said...

Jim,

Unfortunately, this has little to do with kids nowadays, and more to do with crowd mentality aka the "bystander effect".

Google "Kitty Genovese" and you'll see the story that was the topic of numerous classes in social psychology when I was an undergrad student in that field 30+ years ago.

Kitty Genovese was murdered in front of all her neighbors in the 1960s. They saw it happen, they heard her scream and plead for help, and no one called the police... at least not while she was still alive.

The probable reality was that if there had been just one or two people watching, she might have been saved. But because there were so many, the amount of individual responsibility each on-looker felt he or she had was diminished. "Someone else will call." "Someone else will help."

We can extrapolate this to voting: "My vote's not worth much; someone else will vote". Or speaking up when some jerk is saying horrendous things. And on and on.

The social pressure to maintain the status quo and not complain is enormous. And the penalties can be enormous for those who buck the group.

A few years ago I paid several hundred dollars to enroll in a building inspector certification course. Within the first few hours, the instructor made unbelievably racist comments, and then started making jokes about killing cats and throwing them over a fence.

I was furious, but in control of that anger. At break, I went up to the instructor, and tried to tell him that his comments bothered me.

His reaction was over the top. He started yelling at me and kicked me out of the class!!
(It got even worse; he got all the other students to sign statements saying they had no problem with the way he conducted the class, and he threatened to trash me to the Chamber of Commerce, etc.)

It took a lot of energy and follow up, but I eventually got my money back from the owner of the company sponsoring the course; but it was apparent he (the owner) didn't want to rock that boat.

It would have been far easier on me had I kept my mouth shut; most of the others in that class seemed to get a kick out of the instructor’s comments. I was clearly in the minority. But I couldn’t stand by and seem to condone his boorish behaviors. And of course, the worst case scenario happened.

There was a time when the United State enjoyed a vision or fantasy of “rugged individualism”. If that was ever true, it is no longer. Despite our country’s fabulous history, we have become a nation that values conformity over individuality; complacency over outrage; meanness over wonder.

So I will posit that not only were the kids who stood by… or worse, the kids who engaged in the vicious attack… responsible, but I will suggest that their parents are also responsible. Every time their parents modeled sheeplike behavior, they sent a message to those kids. Every time their parents refused to fight an injustice, they told their kids to keep quiet. Those parents need to look to themselves.

As does the media. Every time the media scorns and skewers someone with an original thought, every time the media emphasizes one’s color or clothing or hairstyle over one’s gifts and leadership, the media is colluding to create a nation of people who are unable to stand up and say “THIS IS WRONG!”.

Do the kids deserve to be punished? Of course. Because despite whatever psychological constraints kept them from acting, they still have free will.

Anonymous said...

There is a saying that goes "evil prospers when good men (and women) do nothing."

Like the saying that an omission is the same as a lie, by inaction are we guilty both collectively and individually.

When and how did we become so detached from society as a whole that we can witness injustice and do nothing. In essence fall into a self-contained passivity that reduces us all to being little more than solipsistic children.

Thank you for sharing this Jim.

Anonymous said...

Jim and Marie,
Very well said!!!!
We have a very broken culture.
We must find a ways to counter the "hero" status, and have it be a "natural" thing we do.

We must, each and every one of us, strive to change the world to a more compassionate, respectful one, and with tolerance of each others differences.

Jim you ARE making that difference, one child at a time, lets all start to, or continue to do the same, and change the laws that punish those that get involved. Those laws simply make no sense.

In this country, you can be jailed for trying to help, so we have been desensitized to the pain and destruction of others.

In Germany there is a "Good Samaritan Law" that says - if you don't try and help a person who is hurt or being hurt, you are responsible for what happens to them, and can go to jail, or worse, if you do nothing.

So lets each try and make a positive difference in someones life, have more sensible laws and change the world in a positive way, one person at a time.
Karen Stultz
Whitefield, Maine